Is Biking or Walking Better for Knees?

Knee pain and arthritis are common issues that can make exercise difficult. Choosing low-impact activities like biking and walking can help improve joint health and mobility without causing further pain or damage.

But is one better than the other for your knees? Is biking or walking better for the knees?

Biking is generally better for the knees than walking. It’s a low-impact exercise that reduces stress on the joint as the bike seat supports your body weight, unlike walking which is a weight-bearing exercise. Biking also helps lubricate knee joints, reduce painful symptoms, and improve mobility and range of motion, especially beneficial for those with severe arthritis or inflammation.

Understanding the differences between biking and walking can help you make the best choice for managing knee problems.

What Is the Difference Between Biking and Walking in Terms of Impact on the Knees?

Overall, biking may be slightly better for those with more severe knee pain or arthritis due to its low-impact and circular pedaling motion. However, both offer benefits if done with proper form and gradual progression. Consulting a physical therapist can help determine the best options for your individual knee health.

Here is a table comparing biking vs walking for knee health:

	Biking	Walking
Impact on knees	Low-impact, reduces force on knees	Weight-bearing, force exerted through knees
Knee pain and arthritis	Circular motion can help lubricate joints	Low-impact if done carefully, but potentially more painful
Mobility and range of motion	Pedaling motion flexes/extends knee joint	Gradual flexing and straightening of knees
Muscle strength	Builds leg muscles to support knees	Strengthens leg muscles around knees
Aerobic fitness	Excellent for cardio, works all leg muscle groups	Also great for aerobic conditioning
Weight loss	Helps burn calories and reduce pressure on knees	Weight-bearing can aid fat loss
Best bike type	Stationary, recumbent or exercise bike best for knee issues	N/A
Preventing knee pain	Adjust seat height, keep cadence steady, avoid pushing gears	Maintain proper gait and posture, bend knees slightly

When it comes to knee health, it’s important to understand the difference between weight-bearing and low-impact exercises. Weight-bearing exercises like walking require your legs and knees to support your full body weight against gravity. This places stress on the joint surfaces, ligaments, and muscles surrounding the knee. In contrast, cycling is considered a low-impact exercise because the bike seat supports your body weight, reducing the force on your knees. 

For those with knee pain, inflammation, and stiffness, biking may be preferable to walking because it transfers body weight through the pedals, rather than directly on the knee joint. The circular motion of pedaling can help lubricate knee joints and reduce painful symptoms. However, walking is also a low-impact exercise that can improve knee mobility if done carefully. The impact depends on the individual’s degree of knee problems. Those with severe arthritis or inflammation may benefit more from biking.

Biking and walking can both play an important role in maintaining and improving knee mobility and range of motion. The alternating bending and extending motion of pedaling works the joint through a controlled range, which can help prevent stiffness. Walking also flexes and straightens the knees in a gradual way. For those recovering from knee injuries or surgery, both low-impact exercises can be beneficial in safely regaining flexibility and strength.

How Can Biking and Walking Benefit People With Knee Pain or Arthritis?

Cycling and walking provide strength and endurance training for the muscles surrounding the knees. Building muscle tone in the quads, hamstrings, and calves helps support and stabilize knee joints. Stronger leg muscles can help absorb shock and reduce the impact on knee joints during weight-bearing activities. Biking works all the major muscle groups of the legs in a low-impact way.

Both biking and walking are excellent forms of aerobic exercise that can improve cardiovascular health. Aerobic activity conditions your heart and lungs, helps control blood pressure, and raises your metabolism. The longer duration and rhythmic nature of these activities compared to other exercises maximizes aerobic benefits. Staying physically active through low-impact leg exercise is crucial for overall fitness.

Biking and walking can also facilitate weight loss, which is beneficial for reducing load and pressure on knee joints. The combination of muscle conditioning and aerobic activity helps burn calories and body fat. Additionally, the weight-bearing nature of walking can help build bone density in the hips and legs, improving strength in the areas surrounding the knees.

Which Type of Bike Is Best for People With Knee Problems?

For cycling specifically, exercise bikes, recumbent bikes, and stationary bikes allow you to adjust settings like seat height which helps reduce knee strain. Recumbent bikes also offer back support. Mountain biking can be low-impact with proper technique, but does involve some impact from trail obstacles. Road biking requires bending knees and hunching over handlebars which could aggravate some knee problems.

It’s best to choose a bike that allows a comfortable pedaling motion without overextending your knees or causing discomfort. Customizing bike settings is key. Consulting a bike expert or physical therapist can ensure you select the ideal bike and seat position for your unique needs and knee problems. Riding a bike that fits your body properly will provide the most knee benefits.

How Can You Safely Start a Biking or Walking Program for People With Knee Pain?

If you have knee pain, it’s important to take a gradual approach when starting a new biking or walking routine. Begin with just a few minutes at a time and slowly increase duration. Ride on flat surfaces or walk on even terrain initially. Pedal or stride at a slow, steady pace in an easy gear. Give yourself rest days between sessions to avoid overuse injuries. Using ice and over-the-counter anti-inflammatories can help manage knee discomfort.

Gradual progression over several weeks to months is key to building fitness while preventing knee pain. Slowly increase mileage, terrain difficulty, pedaling resistance, or pace. Avoid aggressive training. Listen to warning signs from your knees like popping, stiffness, and swelling. Be willing to dial back activity if your knees become painful. Patience is required to strengthen knees without strain.

What Are the Best Practices to Prevent Knee Pain While Biking or Walking?

To prevent knee pain while biking or walking, maintain proper form and body positioning. Adjust your seat height to avoid hyperextension. Wear supportive footwear with cushioning. Keep your cadence steady and avoid pushing large gears. Stay focused on low-impact activity and avoid high-intensity training. Strengthen leg muscles through exercises like squats or lunges to better support your knees. Always warm up before cycling or walking.

Using proper technique is critical for knee health in any exercise. Walk with a normal gait and bend knees slightly. Avoid locking knees. Pedal in a smooth circular motion without grinding pressure. Maintaining correct alignment and position will optimize impact on your knees. Consider consulting a physical therapist if you have poor form or posture that could be corrected to prevent knee pain.

Conclusion

For those with knee issues, biking and walking are two excellent low-impact exercises. Cycling avoids pressure through knees by supporting body weight on a seat. Walking gently flexes knees while strengthening legs. Both build crucial muscle tone and aerobic capacity. With proper precautions, those with knee pain or arthritis can safely enjoy cycling and walking to improve joint health.

Beginning a walking or biking routine can feel intimidating when you have knee problems. But adjusting intensity, using proper form, and being patient with gradual gains can make these activities pain-free and beneficial. Simple steps like purchasing a gel seat cover, wearing a knee brace, or icing after a ride can also prevent knee pain. If you proceed carefully, you can strengthen your knees through low-impact exercise. Cycling or walking offers many physical and mental health gains for those with knee issues.

Frequently Asked Questions